Elimination Photoshop


Elimination Assignment

The purpose of the Elimination Assignment was to take images from four different categories and change the meaning of them. This was done by removing or eliminating something using Photoshop. The four categories used for this assignment were: Historical, Fine Art, and Popular Media. The original photos appear on the left, while the edited images using Photoshop are on the right.

Historical:

This first image is known as Fire on Marlborough Street and was taken by Stanley Forman on July 22, 1975. Forman won the Pulitzer Prize for spot news photography in 1976. In Boston, Massachusetts, a fire engulfed an apartment, causing the residents to flee in panic. The two people included in this photo are a young female child and her mother. Both victims took to the fire escape of their apartment when their lives were threatened by intense flames. The fire escape collapsed, leaving both of them to fall to the hard concrete. The mother did not survive the fall but braced the fall for her child; who only survived by landing on top of her mother. The original image is difficult to look at. It evokes a lot of emotion, mostly sadness, and pain for the two victims. The Photoshopped image I created instantaneously changes the emotion evoked from the original photo. The fear on the young girl’s face is still prevalent, but the image implies that they are falling into the sky and to me, this means they are both falling together to a higher place.

Fire on Marlborough Street

edit fallingFinal

      


This image is known as KKK; the original image was taken during a riot in Gainesville, Georgia, 1992, by Todd Robertson via Southern Poverty Law Center. The image holds a lot of irony in and of itself. I wanted to push and expand the meaning behind this contradictory image. I thought the image of a white child, dressed in a KKK outfit, reaching out to two black children would convey an even stronger message of equality, increasing the irony even more. The fact that anyone would dress their child in a KKK outfit astonishes me. I wanted to portray a message that children should not be used to convey something that they are not capable of fully understanding and that racial discrimination is not inherited, but learned behavior; something that can, will and should continue to change.

kkktoddrobertsonphoto  kkkjpeg


 

JenifferL  JenifferLjpg


Fine art:

This next image is a painting called, In Love. I came across it while vacationing in Galveston. I personally met the artist, Michele Grindberg, and visited with her as I toured her gallery. Grindberg explained to me that the fish and the bird represent the love between two different species. I loved the meaning behind the painting and all the things it can potentially represent. I realized by removing the fish from the image, it changed the meaning entirely. Without the fish, there is no longer any representation of love between two beings. The image now seems to capture a lone bird searching for love or scanning the water for prey.

in love  in love


The Nefertiti Bust is a sculpture of an Egyptian royal wife, once married to Akhenaten, an Egyptian Pharaoh. Nefertiti is believed to have ruled for a time after her husband died. Her headdress and jewelry represent her stature and importance. I wanted to strip Nefertiti of these things so that she would appear to be a normal person, without stature. In the edited image of Nefertiti, she seems naked and vulnerable but still beautiful. I think by removing her headdress and jewelry, she becomes like any other peasant during that time; her importance is stripped.

Kinder - Mit 3300 Jahren noch immer begehrt - Soll Nofretete reisen? .  Kinder - Mit 3300 Jahren noch immer begehrt - Soll Nofretete reisen? .


This last image is an extra image I did for fun. I could not resist including it. I love the meaning behind this image. Berndnaut’s lit up cloud, Nimbus II, seems to be floating lonesome in Mariakape church, located in the Netherlands.  Isolated in the church environment, the cloud exudes spirituality and God. Some would say, a visual statement in the debate over faith or lack of faith. When the cloud is removed from the Mariakape church and placed among other clouds you might see every day, it does not stand out. The effect it had on viewers before is now lost. Berndnaut’s Nimbus II cloud looks like any other cloud we would see every day. By removing the cloud from its original setting, I have completely eliminated its importance… Or have I? 😉

cumulusklein  Berndnaut Smilde's

Here is my Elimination PDF: Elimination 

All citations from the Elimination project will be listed in the PDF.


10 thoughts on “Elimination Photoshop

  1. Very good work, I will say that on your falling to the sky picture that original image’s lack of sharpness doesn’t quite match the ocean image. It’s just a minor thing that a trained eye could catch, and it’s not that noticeable unless I enlarge the picture. Very well don though.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Great job on all of your pieces! You definitely have an eye for composition. It was such a smart decision to crop the altered In Love image rather than just removing the fish. It shows that you know how to balance an image. I also like the concept behind the original piece and how you completely negated it by removing the fish. Awesome work!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Loved the altered version of “Fire on Malbourgh Street”. I thought it was very well Photoshopped and your interpretation was spot on. The original evokes many emotions of sorrow and loss and I like how you contrasted that completely by turning it into something positive.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I loved the one that was originally titled “In Love.” I like it because of what it stands for and how the meaning is so dramatically changed. The second one I like is the cloud one. I love how you chose not to eliminate the cloud, but it’s importance, instead. Very creative take on the idea,.

    Like

  5. I really enjoyed your take on this project. My favorite was your first with the Fire on Marlbourgh Street. The original photo shows how close they are to peril and how fleeting death can be as this perfectly-timed shot was captured. I love how to changed all the danger into something playful. The pair seem oddly twisted as the fall and they almost seem like they’re in anti-cravity making your final photo very light and airless.

    Like

  6. Deborah, After looking at your PDF I am thoroughly intrigued by your artistic vision and your attention to detail that is significantly important in pulling your images together while getting across your message. I am extremely impressed with your first manipulation, “Falling to the Sky”! You captured a surrealist quality to the image and produced something that made me question reality and the fantasy world you create in this image. This is really one of the strongest images you have presented. After further inspection of the “Exposed” image, I realized that all the faces on top of her were images of Jennifer Lawerence herself. I like this adds a sense of humor and self-reflection to the image. I’m excited to see more from you!

    Liked by 1 person

    • I admire your “Fire on Malbourgh Street” elimination greatly! The way the splash frames the child and leads the eye downward toward the mother is very jarring. I like the way you layered the splash and child also. Leaving the image upside down is an incredible concept. Great job! The new meaning you created in the “KKK” image is chilling. It creates hateful context between innocent children, illustrating that the ideals of the adults of the period were inhumane, to impose their uncivil beliefs onto their children. I would suggest creating a drop shadow for the KKK child and adding harsher shadows along the lines to help the child fit in the image as a whole better. Great job Deborah!

      Liked by 1 person

  7. The one where you omitted the fish is quite beautiful. One thing that’s very difficult about editing artistic works is keeping the edited portion’s style true to the original work, and I think you definitely succeeded in doing so. Good work.

    Like

  8. Absolutely adore every single picture you chose, and every change to them you made. Great photo choices and changes made. I am blown away by how much creativity and thought was put into you project. Amazing job!

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s